hmmm, i really love both ladies - amazing artists! - but i’ma go w/chrisette’s version! yeah, chrisette’s is a bit more fire, tho i love that really high note around the end of karina’s. so… if you haven’t pick of karinas LP ‘first love’ and chrisette micheles record ‘epiphany’ - great albums! very cool post KILLED THAT! good lookin out

Chrisette has more soul!!, way better not very impressed by karina’s, its not touching & deep like chrisette’s version i dont even think that there is a comparison between the 2 chrisette has won this hands down, karina tried though,dont see why they have the same song that puzzles me,y wud sing something someone has already sung,its not original & they both have it on their cd’s mhmhm.. anyways go cop chrisette michele “Epiphany” the album is awesome!

Hey musicman, thank you so much for posting both songs. I like both versions, but com’on people Karina recorded this song when she was 15 years old, and is not even mixed. I go with Karina, she has more range, more soul, she is more natural, refreshing. chrisette sounds like a voice we’ve heard before. Karina has appeal to the young and old generations. I love Chrisette, but Karina is a beast!!!

Chrisette all the way! She shows the feeling and emotion in every lyric! No doubt in my mind, Chrisette IS soul! Every word she sings is heartfelt! I love her! Karina’s performance was a lack luster. This is Chrisette’s song! it’s on HER album! which is #1 in the whole freakin’ country! Congrats to Chrisette! She’s such a beautiful woman inside & out!!! i loooooovvveeeee her like x infinity! a whole lot! Go pick up EPIPHANY!!! It won’t disappoint!!!!

i like karina’s version…can u post the untagged mp3 download?

Is it bad to like both? lol but naw seriously i like Karinas Betta! Chrisette voice is too strong for this song…

I have to say Chrisette killed it! She sounds so much bettter singing this song. It’s souful and her range is sick!!! It sounds like a much older and mature song when Chrisette sings it.

i think that karina sounded wayyy better than the other girl…they both sound good but i think the other gurl over did it a lil

Chrisette may have overdone it a bit, but I think it makes her recording more interesting and original. Though Karina sounded great, as well, especially for such a young voice.

get some, D man.

I luv both versions but i think karinas voice on that track was betta 4 this song. Karina is madd good i hope she gets more recognition in the future cuz her songs r fiya!

I really like them both…Chrisette’s is more mature and Karina’s is age appropriate.

I liked both artists, but for me Chrisette won hands down, there is no comparison, she smashed it and you believed every word as she sang, yes I said sang it.

chrisette michell ALL DAY she rocked it!!!!!

Chrisette’s version definitely won to me, but it was close, Karina’s was -pretty hot also!

i like both,but i like chrisette michele more

OK the Chrisette version is the TRUTH! I almost have to fight back tears it touches me so. Karina did a solid job she has such a beautiful voice. Though she sings it well she doesn’t get under your skin the way Chrisette does. Chrisette comes from the place of a woman who knows. Karina is still a kid. I mean when Chrisette laments “ALL I EVER THINK ABOUT IS YOU!” after the bridge. I thought i was gonna have a nervous breakdown with her.lol
DON’T SLEEP ON CHRISETTE!
… and I’m gaining love for Karina too